Braces vs. Clear Aligners: Which Is Right for You?

By the team at Borello Orthodontics, serving families in Lake Saint Louis, Kirkwood, and the greater St. Louis area

If you've started looking into orthodontic treatment, you've probably run into the big decision: traditional braces or clear aligners? Both work. Both deliver beautiful results. But they're different tools, and the right one depends on the patient.

A Quick Note: Invisalign vs. Clear Aligners

You've almost certainly heard of Invisalign. It's the most recognizable name in clear aligners, and a lot of people use "Invisalign" as a catch-all term the way we say "Kleenex" for any tissue. But Invisalign is a brand name, and it's just one of several excellent clear aligner systems on the market.

At Borello Orthodontics, we use Angel Aligners, a clear aligner system that's been refined over 20+ years and is now used by orthodontists across North America, Europe, and Asia. We chose Angel Aligners because they were designed by orthodontists for orthodontists (not as a direct-to-consumer product), they use a multi-layer polymer that delivers more precise force to teeth, and they often allow us to offer treatment at a better value without sacrificing clinical quality.

That's why you'll hear us talk about "clear aligners" rather than calling them Invisalign. Same general category, different system.

The Five Things That Actually Matter

1. Compliance: This Is the Big One

This is the single most important factor, and it's where most people underestimate the real difference.

Braces are glued to your teeth. They work 24/7, whether you're thinking about them or not.

Clear aligners need to be worn 20 to 22 hours a day to work. They come out only for eating, drinking anything other than water, and brushing. Everything else (school, sleep, sports, work) happens with the aligners in.

braces vs clear aligners

If you or your teen wears aligners 16 hours a day instead of 22, treatment stalls. Teeth stop moving on schedule. The next set won't fit right. You end up needing refinements, extra sets, extra time, and sometimes a full restart. This isn't a rare problem. It's the single most common reason aligner cases go sideways.

Teens especially can struggle with compliance, not because they're trying to fail, but because a busy teenage life makes consistent 22-hour wear genuinely hard. Adults generally have an easier time, but it still takes real discipline. The honest truth: if we have any doubt about compliance, we'll recommend braces. They're more forgiving.

2. Hygiene: Aligners Win, Clearly

Brushing and flossing with braces is a project. You need to work around brackets and wires, use floss threaders or a water flosser, and spend noticeably more time on hygiene every day. Kids and teens often struggle with this, and we see plenty of patients finish braces treatment with white spots or early decay because brushing got neglected.

Clear aligners come out. You brush and floss exactly like you did before treatment, then put the aligners back in. For patients who are cavity-prone or just want the easiest path to a clean mouth during treatment, this is a real advantage.

3. Mental Load: Braces Are Easier to Forget About

Braces require almost no daily decision-making. They're on your teeth. You brush a bit more carefully, come in for adjustments, and mostly stop thinking about them.

Clear aligners require constant active participation: tracking wear time, remembering to put them back in after every meal or snack, carrying a case everywhere, and swapping to new sets on schedule. For many patients that's fine. For busy parents, teens with hectic schedules, or anyone already stretched thin, it can become a real source of friction. If you value "set it and forget it," braces are the simpler tool.

4. Eating: Aligners Win on Freedom, Braces Win on Spontaneity

This one cuts both ways.

With braces, there's a real list of foods to avoid for the entire length of treatment: sticky candy, gum, popcorn, hard nuts, ice, corn on the cob, whole apples. Break the rules and you risk a popped bracket. But you can eat spontaneously, anywhere, anytime, without taking anything out.

With clear aligners, there are virtually no food restrictions. Take them out, eat what you want, brush, and put them back in. The tradeoff is logistics. You can't grab a snack at a meeting or eat popcorn at a movie without removing and reinserting aligners. Drinks are tricky too: anything other than water requires aligners out, or you risk staining them and trapping sugar against your teeth.

5. Additional Fees: More Likely With Clear Aligners

With braces, small repairs (popped brackets, shifted wires) are typically handled as part of your standard treatment fee.

With clear aligners, a few things can trigger additional costs:

• Lost or broken aligners. Trays thrown out with lunch, forgotten in hotels, or chewed up by dogs (it happens) often come with a replacement fee.

• Refinements. Extra sets of aligners needed when teeth haven't tracked perfectly to plan. Sometimes included up to a certain number, sometimes billed separately beyond that. Compliance issues are the #1 cause.

• Extended treatment. If compliance slips and treatment runs longer than planned, additional fees can apply.

• 
  

We're transparent about these possibilities upfront. Our treatment quotes include what's expected, and we'll always tell you what's covered vs. what would be an additional charge before anything extra is billed. But the general reality is this: braces are more forgiving financially. Aligner cases with strong compliance finish at the quoted price. Aligner cases with weaker compliance often end up costing more than expected.

So Which One Should You Choose, braces vs clear aligners?

Braces are often the better choice if: compliance is a real concern (especially for teens), the case is complex, predictable pricing is a priority, or you value not thinking about treatment day to day.

Clear aligners are often the better choice if: discretion matters, the patient is highly motivated about wear time, oral hygiene is a priority, or you want to keep a normal eating routine.

One thing worth saying: not every patient is a good candidate for clear aligners. Certain bite issues, significant rotations, or severe crowding are better treated with braces regardless of preference. We'll always tell you honestly what your options are and why.

Our Philosophy: The Right Tool for the Right Patient

Borello Orthodontics is a conservative practice, and we don't believe in pushing patients toward a treatment just because it's trendy. Braces and clear aligners are both excellent options in the right hands. The question isn't which is "better" overall, but which is better for you.

Your Next Step: A Complimentary Consultation

The best way to figure out whether braces or clear aligners are right for you or your teen is to come in. We'll examine your teeth, walk you through both options, and give you a specific recommendation based on your case and your life.

Lake Saint Louis, 701 Robert Raymond Drive, Lake Saint Louis, MO 63367

Kirkwood, Woodbine Center 439 S Kirkwood Road, Suite 205, Kirkwood, MO 63122

Schedule your complimentary consultation online or give us a call.

We'd love to meet you and your family.

_________________________________________________________________

Borello Orthodontics has been creating confident smiles in the St. Louis area for over 15 years. Drs. Blake Borello and Taylor Little provide personalized orthodontic care for children, teens, and adults in Lake Saint Louis and Kirkwood.